PennyCollector.com - The official website for elongated pennies, penny books and penny machines Penny Men CTM Group

Report a Location

Location [Legend]CityDesignsImagesUpdated
Crossgates Mall - Finish Line store
1 Crossgates Mall Road
Albany4p 08/11/19
New York State Museum
Empire State Plaza, Madison Avenue
AlbanyGone05/27/22
USS Slater Historical Foundation
Broadway at Quay St
Albany4p 07/22/19
The Ship Gift Shop
22 James St.
Alexandria Bay4p 07/22/18
Mohawk Travel Plaza
New York State Thruway I-90 Eb (Mile Post 172),
Amsterdam4p 11/24/21
Big Dipper Ice Cream
6935 New York 434
Apalachin4p 06/07/20
Bass Pro Shops Sportsman's Center
1579 Clark Street Road
Auburn 4p 08/08/18
Ausable Chasm
Route 9
Ausable ForksGone08/28/18
Fire Island Ferry Terminal
99 Maple Ave.
Bay Shore4p 09/18/18
Bear Mountain Inn
55 Hessian Drive
Bear Mountain4p 07/10/21
Midway State Park
4859 Route 430
Bemus PointGone06/18/22
Old Bethpage Village Restoration
Round Swamp Rd.
Bethpage4p 07/08/18
Binghamton Zoo at Ross Park
185 Park Avenue
Binghamton4p 06/22/22
Roberson Museum and Science Center
30 Front Street
Binghamton 4p 08/05/20
Buffalo Museum of Science
1020 Humboldt Parkway
Buffalo4p 03/06/22
Buffalo Zoo
300 Parkside Ave.
Buffalo8p 02/06/22
Explore & More – The Ralph C. Wilson, Jr. Children’s Museum
130 Main St
Buffalo4p 06/18/22
The Buffalo History Museum
1 Museum Court
Buffalo4p 03/06/22
Woodbury Common Premium Outlets
498 Red Apple Court
Central ValleyGone07/27/17
Chautauqua Institution
1 Ames Ave
Chautauqua3p 05/10/22
Cabela's Outdoor Gear
2003 Walden Avenue
Cheektowaga Gone09/28/20
NY State Thruway, Chittenango Travel Plaza
I-90 Eastbound, Milepost 266
ChittenangoGone08/03/16
NY State Thruway, Clarence Travel Plaza
I-90 Westbound, Milepost 412
ClarenceGone02/25/16
Karla's Christmas Shoppe
500 Riverside Drive
Clayton4p 06/13/19
NY State Thruway, Clifton Springs Travel Plaza
I-90 Eastbound, Milepost 337
Clifton SpringsGone10/13/20
Dutch Village Restaurant
8729 E. Main St.
Clymer4p 02/25/22
Doubleday Cafe
93 Main Street
CooperstownGone07/25/17
National Pastime
81 Main Street
CooperstownGone10/16/20
Pioneer Sports Cards Store
106 Main Street
Cooperstown3p 08/07/18
The Home Plate/Tj's Restaurant
124 Main Street
CooperstownMoved06/25/17
Yastrzemski Sports
75 Main Street
Cooperstown4p 06/04/22
NY State Thruway, Pembroke Travel Plaza
I-90 Eastbound, Milepost 397
CorfuGone08/26/16
Darien Lake Theme Park Resort
9993 Allegheny Road
Darien Center6p 08/12/21
Six Flags Darien Lake
9993 Allegheny Road
Darien CenterGone10/19/20
Queens Center Mall
90-15 Queens Boulevard
ElmhurstGone10/19/20
Eldridge Park
In the carousel building
Elmira4p 05/04/19
Harris Hill
557 Harris Hill Road
Elmira4p 06/25/21
Lollypop Farm
99 Victor Road
Fairport4m 02/26/22
Adventureland Amusement Park
2245 Route 110
FarmingdaleGone10/19/20
Citi Field / New York Mets Baseball
Roosevelt Avenue
Flushing3p 09/26/19
Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard
288 Goose Street
Fly CreekGone06/13/19
Cradle of Aviation Museum
Charles Lindbergh Blvd
Garden City4p 09/18/18
Jellystone Park
50 Bevier Road
Gardiner4p 07/14/21
Seneca Lake State Park
Visitor's Center
GenevaMoved10/12/20
Adirondack Animal Land
3554 State Highway 30
Gloversville (near Broadlbin)4m 07/23/19
Erie County Agricultural Society/Fairgrounds
5600 McKinley Parkway
Hamburg4p 08/12/19
Herkimer Diamond Mines & KOA Campground
4626 New York 28
HerkimerGone10/04/17
Howes Cavern
255 Discovery Dr,
Howes Cave4m 04/02/22
Cayunga Nature Center
1420 Taughannock Blvd
Ithaca4p 02/12/22
Museum of the Earth
1259 Trumansburg Road
Ithaca4p 02/12/22
Sunny Days of Ithaca
215 E State St
Ithaca4p 02/12/22
Lucille Ball Desi Arnaz Museum & Center for Comedy
2 West 3rd St
Jamestown2p 02/26/22
National Comedy Center
203 W. 2nd Street
Jamestown4p 02/26/22
$2 T-Shirt Outlet
197 Canada St
Lake GeorgeMoved06/30/20
Across the street from the Welcome Center
Beach Road
Lake George4p 07/10/18
Beef Jerky Outlet
1424 Route 9, Space #8A
Lake George4p 06/13/22
Fort William Henry Museum
48 Canada Street
Lake George4p 06/13/22
Riley's Supercenter
1839 U.S. Route 9
Lake George 4p 06/13/22
Rileys at the Lake - Downtown
141 Canada St
Lake George4p 06/13/22
Village Emporium
199 Canada Street (State Route 9)
Lake George3p 06/13/22
Waterfront Living/ Lake George
155 Canada St.
Lake George4p 06/13/22
Six Flags Great Escape Lodge & Indoor Waterpark
1172 State Route 9 (PO Box 511)
Lake George (Queensbury)Gone09/12/21
Ulster Travel Plaza
1-87 Southbound, Milepost 96
Lake Katrine4p 08/25/19
High Peaks Gift Shop - Alpine Mall
125 Main St.
Lake PlacidMoved07/07/16
Riley's North of Lake Placid
2420 Main St
Lake PlacidGone06/01/18
NY State Thruway, Rest Stop
I-90 W
LancasterGone08/26/16
Eisenhower Lock
Eisenhower Lock, Massena, NY 13662
Massena4p 07/10/19
Modena Travel Plaza
I-87S Milepost 66 Southbound
Modena4p 03/31/22
Montauk Point Lighthouse
2000 Montauk Highway
MontaukGone06/18/16
Wave Wear Shop
MontaukGone10/13/20
Flower Divas
314 W Main St
Montour Falls 4p 09/03/20
Genesee Country Village & Museum
1410 Flint Hill Road
Mumford4p 11/30/19
Rochester Science Museum - Cumming Nature Center
6472 Gulick Road
Naples1p 06/23/19
Funfuzion at New Roc City
19 Le Count Place
New RochelleGone11/21/21
Bronx Zoo/Wildlife Conservation Society
2300 Southern Boulevard
New York City (Bronx)32p 5t 09/26/21
Yankee Stadium Team Store/New York Yankees Baseball
Yankee Stadium
New York City (Bronx)8p 1t 05/11/22
Coney Island Arcade
12th Street and Surf Avenue
New York City (Brooklyn)Gone07/25/17
Deno's Wonderwheel Park (Coney Island)
3059 Denos Vourderis Place (Formerly West 12th St.)
New York City (Brooklyn)Gone01/22/19
Jewish Children's Museum
792 Eastern Parkway
New York City (Brooklyn)4p 02/10/20
New York Aquarium
Boardwalk at West 8th Street
New York City (Brooklyn)8p 09/25/21
Prospect Park Zoo
450 Flatbush Avenue
New York City (Brooklyn)4p 10/27/16
American Museum of Natural History
79th Street at Central Park West
New York City (Manhattan)16p 05/12/22
Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream Shop
200 W 44th St.
New York City (Manhattan)4p 01/11/22
Bubba Gump Shrimp Company
1501 Broadway
New York City (Manhattan)4p 01/11/22
Central Park Zoo and Wildlife Center
5th Avenue at 64th Street
New York City (Manhattan)16p 4t 08/28/21
Daredevil Tattoo
141 Division St Ste 2
New York City (Manhattan)4p 06/22/20
Dave and Buster's
234 W. 42nd St., 3rd Floor
New York City (Manhattan)4p 05/11/22
Easy Internet Cafe
234 West 42nd Street
New York City (Manhattan)Moved10/14/20
Ellen's Stardust Diner
1650 Broadway at 51st Street
New York City (Manhattan)Gone05/11/22
Empire State Building
350 5th Avenue
New York City (Manhattan)Moved06/22/19
ESPN Zone
1472 Broadway at 42nd Street
New York City (Manhattan)Gone07/23/17
FAO Schwarz
767 5th Avenue @ 58th St.
New York City (Manhattan)Gone10/13/20
Grand Slam New York
1557 Broadway
New York City (Manhattan)Gone05/14/21
Gray Line Visitor Center (Port Authority Bus Terminal)
319 West 42nd st (Port Authority Bus Terminal)
New York City (Manhattan)Gone05/11/22
Hard Rock Cafe
1501 Broadway
New York City (Manhattan)4p 05/11/22
Liberty Empire, Inc
339 5th Avenue(between 33rd and 34th),
New York City (Manhattan)Gone05/01/22
Little Italy Pizza
33-56-54th Street
New York City (Manhattan)Gone10/07/18
M&M's World
1600 Broadway at 48th Street (Times Square)
New York City (Manhattan)16p 05/11/22
Madame Tussauds
234 West 42nd Street, between 7th and 8th
New York City (Manhattan)13p 3t 05/11/22
Modell's Sporting Goods at Times Square
234 W 42nd St
New York City (Manhattan)Gone10/15/20
New York City Mini Mall gift shop
217 B Canal st (Chinatown)
New York City (Manhattan)Gone07/24/17
NY Loves Us
30 Vesey St
New York City (Manhattan)4p 05/08/22
NY Waterway Ferry - Midtown Ferry
459 12th Ave
New York City (Manhattan)3p 05/11/22
NY Waterways Ferry Terminal
West Side Highway at W. 38th St.
New York City (Manhattan)Gone10/14/20
One World Trade Center - One World Observatory
285 Fulton Street 100th Floor
New York City (Manhattan)10p 05/11/22
Phantom of Broadway Gifts
1653 Broadway between 51st & 52nd Streets
New York City (Manhattan)Gone05/25/16
Ripley's Believe It or Not, Times Square
234 West 42nd St.
New York City (Manhattan)Gone05/15/21
Sanrio (Hello Kitty Store)
233 West 42nd Street
New York City (Manhattan)Moved07/25/17
Sbarro Pizza (Chinatown)
296 Canal Street at Broadway
New York City (Manhattan)Gone10/07/18
Sbarro Pizza (Times Square)
1606 Broadway at 49th Street
New York City (Manhattan)Gone07/25/17
Sotheby's Auctions
1334 York Ave
New York City (Manhattan)Gone10/30/19
South Street Seaport Mall
Pier 17 Pavilion (FDR Drive @ Fulton St.)
New York City (Manhattan)Gone10/13/20
Souvenir World
5th Ave between 36th and 37th Streets
New York City (Manhattan)Gone10/22/20
St. Patrick's Cathedral
5th Avenue between 50th/51st
New York City (Manhattan)5t 12/08/18
The Funny Store
693 8th Avenue between W. 43rd & W. 44th Streets
New York City (Manhattan)Moved10/19/20
Times Square Information Center
1560 Broadway between 46th & 47th Streets
New York City (Manhattan)Gone01/15/17
Toys - R - Us
1514 BROADWAY AT 44TH S Times Square
New York City (Manhattan)Gone02/27/18
U.S.S. Intrepid Sea, Air & Space Museum
Pier 86, West 46th Street & 12th Avenue
New York City (Manhattan)12p 4t 05/11/22
World Trade Center, top Tower Observatory.
New York City (Manhattan)Gone03/19/21
Ripley's Believe it Or Not, Time Square
Address (physical) 234 West 42nd Street
New York City (Mantahhen)5p 01/03/20
New York Hall of Science
47-01 111th Street
New York City (Queens)4p 4t 02/20/22
Queens Zoo
53-51 111th Street
New York City (Queens)5p 07/08/18
Staten Island Zoo
614 Broadway
New York City (Staten Island)4p 10/23/21
Ellis Island Immigration Museum
Ellis Island
New York Harbor8p 6t 05/11/22
Statue of Liberty National Monument
Liberty Island
New York Harbor7t 05/11/22
McDonalds (rest area)
Route 87
NewburghGone12/31/18
Orange County Choppers Retail Store
14 Crossroads Court
NewburghGone06/20/18
Aquarium of Niagara
701 Whirpool St
Niagara Falls1p 07/05/20
Bollywood Bistro
310 Rainbow Boulevard South
Niagara FallsGone10/23/20
Cave of the Winds Gift Shop
Goat Island Road
Niagara Falls4t 8p 05/30/22
Daredevil Museum
303 Rainbow Boulevard atThird Street
Niagara FallsGone07/13/21
Fallside Cafe & Souvenirs
399 Rainbow Blvd
Niagara FallsGone07/25/17
Flight of Angels Balloon Ride
310 Rainbow Blvd.S
Niagara FallsGone10/19/20
Hard Rock Cafe
333 Prospect St
Niagara Falls 4p 03/19/22
Haunted House of Wax
222 Rainbow Blvd
Niagara Falls3n 05/26/22
Honeymoon Capital Souvenir Shop
16 Rainbow Blvd
Niagara Falls4p 03/19/22
Niagara Aerospace Museum
9990 Porter Road
Niagara Falls1d 02/11/22
Niagara Factory Outlet
1900 Military Road
Niagara FallsGone07/25/17
Niagara Falls State Park
Niagara Falls State Park
Niagara Falls24p 4t 02/06/22
Niagara Wax Museum of History
303 Prospect Street
Niagara Falls1p 07/03/20
Orin Lehman Visitor's Center
Niagara FallsMoved07/25/17
Putt Niagara
310 Rainbow Blvd. South
Niagara FallsMoved07/25/17
Quality Hotel & Suites
240 1st Street
Niagara Falls8p 05/30/22
Rainforest Café - Niagara
c/o Sheraton Hotel 300 Third Street
Niagara Falls4p 02/05/22
Smokin Joes Fun Center
Rainbow Boulevard
Niagara FallsGone07/25/17
Souvenirs at the Point
One Prospect Point
Niagara FallsGone10/19/20
Top of the Falls Gift Shop
Goat Island RD
Niagara FallsMoved05/30/22
Mitchell's Restaurant
2756 Long Beach Road
OceansideGone10/15/20
Olcott Beach Carousel Park
5979 Main St
Olcott3p 05/30/22
ADK Home
3038 State Route 28
Old Forge4p 07/25/16
Enchanted Forest Water Safari
3183 State Route 28
Old Forge1p 07/24/19
NY State Thruway, Oneida Travel Plaza
I-90 Eastbound, Milepost 244
OneidaGone08/18/21
Phoenicia Diner
5681 NY-28, Phoenicia, NY 12464
Phoenicia4p 11/03/20
Chandler's Square Ice cream shop
30 Chandler Square
Port JeffersonGone07/25/17
Harbor Square Mall/ Out of This World Gift Shop
134 Main Street
Port JeffersonGone07/08/18
Harbor Square Mall/ Sea Creations
134 Main Street
Port Jefferson4p 06/07/19
Once Upon a Christmas
22 Mill Creek Road
Port Jefferson Moved07/24/17
Port Jeff Bowl
31 Cherub Drive
Port Jefferson StationGone06/07/19
Letchworth State Park Visitor Center
6375 Park Rd
Portageville4m 04/02/22
Natural Stone Bridge and Caves Park
535 Stone Bridge Road
Pottersville1d 4p 07/23/19
Six Flag's Great Escape Lodge & Indoor Waterpark
89 Six Flags Drive
Queensbury6p 10/20/20
The Vintage Variety Store
129 Main St
RandolphGone07/25/17
Long Island Aquarium & Exhibition Cntr (Was Atlantis Marine World Aqu)
431 E Main St
Riverhead8p 06/03/22
Splish Splash
2549 Splish Splash Drive
RiverheadGone07/25/17
National Museum of Play (formally Strong Museum)
1 Manhattan Square Drive
Rochester8p 02/26/22
Rochester Museum & Science Center
657 East Ave
Rochester5p 12/23/19
Seabreeze Park
4600 Culver Road
RochesterGone10/14/20
Seneca Park Zoo
2222 Saint Paul Street
Rochester8p 02/26/22
Allegany State Park
2373 ASP, Rte 1
Salamanca4p 03/31/22
Impressions of Saratoga
368 Broadway Avenue
Saratoga Springs3p 06/13/22
Malden Travel Plaza
I-87 North Mile marker 103
Saugerties3p 04/23/22
NY State Thruway, Guilderland Travel Plaza
I-90 Eastbound, Mile Marker 153
Schenectady4p 10/25/21
NY State Thruway, Scottsville Travel Plaza
I-90 Eastbound, Milepost 366
ScottsvilleGone03/06/16
Seneca Falls Visitor Center
89 Fall Street
Seneca Falls4p 01/09/21
NY State Thruway, Ramapo Travel Plaza - Southbound
1-87 Southbound, Milepost 33
Sloatsburg4p 11/21/21
NY State Thruway, Sloatsburg Service Area - Northbound
1-87 northbound, Milepost 33
Sloatsburg8p 08/19/21
Waterman Family Gift Shop
52 East Main Street
Springville4p 05/23/22
Sylvan Beach Amusement Park
112 Bridge
Sylvan BeachGone03/14/19
Rosamond Gifford Zoo at Burnet Park
One Conservation Place
Syracuse8p 04/16/22
Rubenstein Museum of Science & Technology (MOST)
500 South Franklin Street
Syracuse1p 02/10/22
WonderWorks
9090 Destiny USA Dr
Syracuse3p 01/21/22
Fort Ticonderoga
102 Fort Ti Road
Ticonderoga4p 03/21/21
Utica Zoo
99 Steele Hill Road
Utica4p 04/08/21
NY State Thruway, Seneca Travel Plaza
I-90 Westbound, Milepost 350
VictorGone03/06/16
NY State Thruway, Modena Travel Plaza (Southbound)
I-87 South, Milepost 66
Wallkill4p 04/06/19
NY State Thruway, Plattekill Travel Plaza - Northbound
I-87 North, Milepost 66
WallkillGone10/15/20
Jones Beach State Park
Ocean Parkway
WantaghGone10/19/20
Burrville Cider Mill
WatertownGone10/19/20
New York State Zoo at Thompson Park
1 Thompson Park
WatertownGone10/12/20
Famous Brands
Franklin ST.
Watkins Glen4p 05/28/22
Teddy Bears Den
3428 VanDyke Rd
Watkins GlenGone10/12/20
Watkins Glen Gift Shop
Watkins GlenGone10/13/20
Watkins Glen State Park
Route 14
Watkins GlenGone10/16/20
West Point Military Academy Visitors Center
Building 2107, West Point Hwy
West Point1p 10/18/20
Legoland Discovery Center Westchester
39 Fitzgerald Street
Yonkers4p 4t 10/14/20